Skip to main content
😊🩵🍭 FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS $50+ 😊🩵🍭
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 15,000+ HAPPY CUSTOMERS
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 15,000+ HAPPY CUSTOMERS
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 15,000+ HAPPY CUSTOMERS
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 15,000+ HAPPY CUSTOMERS
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 15,000+ HAPPY CUSTOMERS
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 15,000+ HAPPY CUSTOMERS
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 15,000+ HAPPY CUSTOMERS
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 15,000+ HAPPY CUSTOMERS
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 15,000+ HAPPY CUSTOMERS
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 15,000+ HAPPY CUSTOMERS
Mystery Fudge
Mystery Fudge
Mystery Fudge
Mystery Fudge

Mystery Fudge

$13.95

Feelin’ bold? Go Mystery Mode.

Step out of the ordinary and into the delicious unknown with our Mystery Fudge. Whether it’s a fan favorite, a limited-time flavor, or something totally wild from Callie’s secret stash, one thing’s for sure—it’ll be rich, creamy, and downright irresistible. Let us surprise you. You bring the sweet tooth.

Every order is made fresh to order from our candy kitchen in Two Harbors, Minnesota! Please expect your order to ship in 3-4 business days, as we make all our fudge orders fresh. A confirmation email will be sent to you once the order is placed. Once your fudge is made and sent out, shipping typically takes between 3-6 business days. A tracking code will be sent via email once the carrier receives the package.

For more information on how we ship your treats, please visit our Shipping Policy!
Made Fresh Daily
Simple Ingredients
Always Delicious
Made Fresh Daily
Simple Ingredients
Always Delicious
Made Fresh Daily
Simple Ingredients
Always Delicious
Made Fresh Daily
Simple Ingredients
Always Delicious
Made Fresh Daily
Simple Ingredients
Always Delicious
Made Fresh Daily
Simple Ingredients
Always Delicious
Made Fresh Daily
Simple Ingredients
Always Delicious
Made Fresh Daily
Simple Ingredients
Always Delicious
Made Fresh Daily
Simple Ingredients
Always Delicious
Made Fresh Daily
Simple Ingredients
Always Delicious

Crafted with Love

From the smoothest fudge to the crunchiest popcorn, our all-encompassing collection promises a delightful experience for every taste bud.

How Our Fudge Is Made:

All our fudge is handmade fresh using copper kettles in our retail store.

Step 1.

Mix base ingredients in copper kettles.

Step 2.

Add main ingredients to add unique flavor.

Step 3.

Place fudge in settling pan.

Step 4.

Evenly spread and let fudge cool.

Customer Reviews

Based on 28 reviews
61%
(17)
11%
(3)
14%
(4)
4%
(1)
11%
(3)
100.0
D
D

Oh my, so good!

D
D F
summertime flavor

we found the mystery fudge to be 'creamsicle' and just as delicious as it sounds

s
shirley kimball
yuck!

Have no idea which fudge was the mystery on. They were all yucky! I am 82 not young with the flavors you sent me.

C
Carole Porter
Mystery

I gave to my son

J
JOHN WEBB
Just OK

The choc fudge seems dry eveen when out of fridge for a while. Don't care for mystery addition. Just too sweet for me.

123
Shop
Customer Support
About Us
Get Involved

2025 © Callie's Sweets

The Sweetest Store on the North Shore!